Paul John Brilliance 46%
Batch: 8.NO-001/ Btl: July 2013/ Tasted: Dec 2013
Aromas of glossy barley with a slight nutty and gristy note. Lightly perfumed with a touch of orange blossom and vanilla. Fresher and less oaked than the Amrut with a sliver of lime, gentle crumbly spice and a light herbal note. With time the American oak does fill out but it doesn’t overwhelm the spirit.
The palate is full of silky barley and gentle, lightly oiled orange blossom. Stunning depth with the lightly sugared vanillins coming through brining a light custard powder intimation. Very long and spicy with a fresh citrus note balancing. It finishes with the returning barley, dusted with cocoa powder and the citrus lingering.
Paul John Brilliance 46%
First and Second Fill American oak barrels/ Batch 3 Oct 2016/ Tasted: May 2017
Full, Fragrant, aromatic, juicy and barley’d aromas with hints of manuka honey, sweet oak and a touch of barky, cinnamon spice, liquorice and salt. The aromas darken a little with time as the malt appears and the oak becomes wonderfully nutty and creamy.
The palate is quite salty to begin with, followed by barley, juicy apricot, vanilla, manuka honey and gentle wood spices. Wonderfully deep and a lovely, grippy, spicy middle. Long and continuing salty with marzipan, sugared almonds, malt and a dusting of cocoa powder.
Paul John Edited 46%
Peated/ Batch: 8.NO-001/ Btl: July 2013/ Tasted: Dec 2013
The aromas are fresh and herbal with a slight mintiness, before the dry, slightly dusty and lightly violet scented peat drifts in along with a touch of molasses/ tar. This is followed by gristy, sweet barley notes and some taught, chocolaty oak notes. Very juicy and elegant.
The palate opens with the polished barley followed by some lightly herbal notes before the gentle dry peat and light molasses notes appear. Lovely balance and intensity with the barley becoming very juicy and a lovely dark/ milk chocolate battle happening on the middle. Vibrant and fresh with a salty, lightly oiled vanilla, crunchy spices, peat and chocolaty tannin finish. Very impressive.
Paul John Edited 46%
Vatting of peated and un-peated whisky (5-7 years old). Overall 8-10PPM
First and Second Fill American oak barrels/ Batch 3 Oct 2016/ Tasted: May 2017
The nose is fresh and crisp and reasonably phenolic with sweet honey beneath. Hints of minty, almost medicinal herbs, liquorice, tar, spice and violets. The peat becomes quite gritty and possibly a little Bowmore-like. With time and the vanilla oak and salt puts in an appearance.
The palate opens with the barley and honey, followed by a gentler, earthier and smokier peat character. Hints of tar and oak come through on the middle along with some developing medicinal and violet notes. Seriously juicy with a dry, peat smoke and dark chocolate finish and lingering vibrant salty notes. There’s a lovely complexity to the peat character.
Paul John Bold 46%
Whisky peated to 25-30PPM (5-7 years old)
First Fill American oak barrels/ Batch 1 May 2016/ Tasted: May 2017
The nose has a very Laphroaig-esque, violet scented peat character. Bold, tarry,briny, chlorinated and medicinal. Underneath lays some lovely honey, barley and citrus. More focused and tart (as opposed to the edited) but the lovely sweet barley and oak balances.
The palate kicks off with the almost tart citrus and barley, followed by dusty, medicinal-peat, tar and salt. Intense, vibrant and sooty with developing notes of treacle, liquorice and mocha. Lovely mouth puckering coastal finish with lingering peat dust and faint parma violet notes. Yes, that’s bold alright!
Paul John Select Cask Classic 55.2%
Tasted: Feb 2016
Nose: Very intense and very winey and petrol with hints of straw, white fruit and honey. With time a touch of herbal rye-like notes and coffee.
Palate: Again straw-like white fruit and honey. Quite alcoholic with a hint of rose oil and gentle, herbal spice.
Finish: Long and herbal.
Conclusion: Very intriguing, wine finished perhaps?
Paul John Select Cask Classic 55.2%
Re-Tasted: July 2016
Nose: Heavy and oily with barley, oak and honey so thick you could cut it with a knife! Lightly perfumed with guava, lime, apricot, vanilla and heather-like notes. Water emphasises the lime and makes it fresher.
Palate: Full and honeyed with fleshy apricot, malt biscuits and barley. Seriously deep and concentrated with a beautiful seam of refreshing lime. Water makes it extremely juicy and unctuous.
Finish: Long and remaining honeyed and herbal with a suburb sweet/ dry balance. Water brings out a touch of dry spice.
Conclusion: The depth and complexity of this malt is simply breathtaking.
Paul John Select Cask Classic 55.2%
Batch 1 May 2016/ Tasted: May 2017
Intense aromas of dusty barley, banana fritters and rye-like herbs, along with straw, coffee, malt and charred oak. It develops a light coastal note but the oak and oily barley intensity is what steals the show. Stunning depth and balance.
Rich and dense on the palate with with oily barely, straw and rye-like herbs. Again there’s plenty of charred oak and a touch of honey and spice. Long and intense with a light rose petal marc, which makes it feel younger than 7 years old, and marzipan . Slightly biscuit and malty after-taste.
Water brings out a lightly perfumed, estery tropical bananary fruit and malt biscuits, now the oak has receded. There’s also hints of honeycomb and salt. The palate is likewise less oaky and more honeyed, sweeter and maltier with a lovely, soft, tropical dénouement. Very malty finish with some slightly tannic and grippy spices.
Paul John Select Cask Peated 55.5%
Tasted: July 2016
Nose: Initially sharp and astringent with plenty of peat and coffee. Then the honey arrives to balance. Hints of malt biscuits, earth and light medicinal notes follow along with charred beachwood.
Palate: Weighty and full with barley, oak and honey. It takes awhile for the peat to arrive but it builds pleasantly with a lightly medicinal character. Water makes it quite citric with the oak becoming slightly grainy and a hint of kerosene appearing.
Finish: Long and intense with mouth-coating, slightly sooty peat and lingering medicinal notes. Water makes the peat very herbal and again brings out a touch of kerosene.
Conclusion: It doesn’t matter what country it comes from, but great whisky is still great whisky.
Paul John Select Cask Peated 55.5%
Re-Tasted: Feb 2017
Nose: Intense, phenolic, briny, coastal laced peat. Hints of burnt wood follow and a touch of sweet barley adds a counterpoint. Vibrant, windswept and Ardbeggy in character.
Palate: Full and gloriously rounded with the barley up first. The peat is subtler and dustier in character with hints of tar, coal and earth. Good complexity with building burnt wood, rope, salt and iodine.
Finish: Long, astringent and salty with a lightly smoked after-taste.
Conclusion: Now, that’s good!
Paul John Select Cask Peated 55.5%
Batch 1 June 2016/ Tasted: May 2017
The nose is quite subtle on the peat and like the edited shows a lovely complexity of earthy peat and gently medicinal Islay peat. Fresh, salty and malty with a touch of toasted toffee, Demerara sugar, tar and salty infused citrus. Multi-layered and majestic with an underlying robust barley’d spirit.
The palate opens with the sweet barley and subtle honey before the medicinal and sooty, sweet, earthy peat arrives. Like the nose it is very fresh and citric with plenty of coastal notes. Light mocha finish with mouth-watering citric notes and lingering menthol and dry, medicinal peat.
Water emphasises the tar and violets. Seriously fresh and crisp now with a nostril coating saltiness. The palate is softer and sootier with more honeyed fruit and malt. The peat is subtler now but still present, although it’s still pretty salty. Now, that’s a damn fine malt!
Paul John Single Cask 59.7%
Cask 1444/ Tasted: Jan 2015
Nose: Woody and spicy with malt so thick you could cut it with a knife! Quite herbal with dark wheat, hops, young and herbal rye-like notes .Bready and biscuit with hints of honey, green apples and almost grainy note. Excellent complexity and intensity with a light vanilla oak note coming through. Water emphasises the honey and herbal notes but does make the aromas a little soapy.
Palate: Sweet barley, malt, herbs and digestive biscuits and masking alcohol. Water softens and makes it maltier and brings out hints of wheat, treacle and herbs, which like the nose seem quite rye-like.
Finish: Mouth-watering and intense with the herbal notes out distancing the alcohol.
Conclusion: Wow, this has come out of left field. Is it made from some kind of multi-grain mash?
Paul John Single Cask – Peated 59.2%
Cask 777/ Tasted: Mar 2015
Nose: Dusty and spicy – cinnamon, nutmeg, turmeric, sooty peat and powdered cedar wood tannins. Quite herbal with a light medicinal demeanour along with a light salty astringency. The lovely, mature oak adds structure in the background.
Palate: A little more robust than the nose would suggest as the oak is a little more forward but not dominating. Again dusty, spicy-peat, treacle and a touch of dried fruit appear. Quite herbal on the middle with an alcohol accented astringency.
Finish: Mouth-watering with coal/peat dust along with herbal/medicinal peat coated fruit. Yep! It’s dusty!
Conclusion: Reminds me of a dusty, mature Bowmore. Stunning stuff.